Skip to main content


By August 13, 2019Music

It all started with The Beatles, Herman’s Hermits, Buffalo Springfield and Creedence Clearwater Revival. Since the sixties I’ve been an obsessive consumer of music — first on vinyl, then cassette and for the past 30 years on CD.

My selective collection of 1,000 or so CDs balances the classics of my youth with an ever-expanding array of new artists representing mostly indie rock, Britpop and Americana along with the exceptional pop star or rapper.

The essence of my obsession is not entirely clear. That is to say, the attraction could be emotional, physical, aural or some combination. In truth, more than actually listening to the music, the most satisfying moment comes in shopping for the coveted CD among the record store racks.

The hunting and gathering, that’s what I live for. Which is why it was so painful to see my local independent record store, Dimple Records in Sacramento face the same demise as other brick-and-mortar retailers — the inability to compete with convenient, cheaper online sources.


One by one music retailers are facing the consequences of the evolving dynamics of music consumption. Whereby successful booksellers have become hubs for arts, culture and community events, and add coffee shops, meeting spaces and related product lines, record stores seem only to embrace the past.

With few exceptions, there are no cross-promotions with local music venues or artists, with pubs, eateries or coffee shops, or with local schools and colleges. Record stores display little creativity in expanding their product lines. An obvious example would be to tease and appease collectors with attractive and essential CD cases and stands. Then again, convenience never appeared to be a point of emphasis. None offer complimentary wi-fi or customer bathrooms to extend browsing time. Worst of all, though, is when record stores squander their single greatest advantage over online buying: personal service.

Whether with Tower Records, which began in Sacramento and went on to rule the retail music industry worldwide before going bankrupt; Virgin, another massive multi-national retail failure; and recently the independent chain Dimple, I can count on one hand the number of times a clerk asked if I needed assistance, shared interest in a purchase, or acknowledged me as a regular customer.


California’s music retailers are an endangered species. Still alive, though, are Boo Boo Records in San Luis Obispo and Amoeba Music in San Francisco, Berkeley and Los Angeles. Both operations continue to prove there are enough music patrons to support creative retailing and quality customer service.

Though the breed of music lovers who still appreciate both hearing and holding the music of their favorite artists is shrinking, the appeal of CDs is as likely as the cyclical resurgence of vinyl albums to be resuscitated. For confident and adaptable record store owners, life will go on. With the full backing of obsessive, possessive music consumers like me who appreciate a personal, tactile shopping experience.


  • Gary Greenbaum says:

    Sad to see it go.

  • edwitts says:

    They would still be in business if you weren’t taking so many vacations.

  • Steven Vanderville says:

    You know I share your passion for music and I’m also disappointed to see Dimple go. My daughter, now 17, is a couple years into her own music obsession and was only able to experience Dimple a couple of times. It’s the only record store she’ll remember when she’s older.

    I’ve embraced digital music but even that medium is slipping away from me. My ipod is a relic. Apple EOL’ed itunes, which I used to organize, experience, and obsess over my own library. And I can’t bring myself to pay for streaming music I don’t own. I refuse to be passively satisfied with whatever track the algorithm shuffles up for me.

    We evolve or die and that’s healthy. But it’s still sad and disappointing when the good stuff goes extinct.

    • greenbaumgpr says:

      I suppose the possessive nature of my music collecting should be of concern. Though the physical presence of CDs makes for convenient reminders of my options.

  • Jack Isler says:

    Just yesterday Kathy and I were lamenting the days of going to Tower records and literally spending the afternoon listening to and looking for the next best CD. The feelings had there could never be replicated or replaced.

    • greenbaumgpr says:

      Agreed! Which made it an incredible stroke of good fortune to recently happen onto one of the few remaining Tower Records stores in Dublin, Ireland. I practically had to be pried out of there after a couple hours of browsing and buying.

Leave a Reply